I think as it is there is the issue of double NAT.
I think I have to setup a static route in the WAN router. But the last time I tried I had to factory reset the WAN router because nothing was working anymore.
How should the static routing look and how can I check if indeed double NAT is occuring in my network?
For this example the WAN router's LAN is 192.168.0.1/24 and the OpenWrt router's LAN is 192.168.1.1/24.
In the WAN router first create a DHCP reservation so that the OpenWrt router has a consistent IP address such as 192.168.0.20.
If you chose an IP different from the existing leased IP, restart the OpenWrt router or at least restart the network so it picks up the new IP.
Then add a route for the second LAN (192.168.1.0/24) via 192.168.0.20 which is the reserved IP of the OpenWrt router on the first router's LAN.
These changes should not otherwise affect the operation of the WAN router at all even if the OpenWrt router is not connected.
Then go to the OpenWrt router firewall setting and uncheck "masquerade" on the WAN and restart the firewall. No more double NAT.
I forgot to note this: some ISP devices will handle static routes - but then oddly will only NAT to the Internet for the subnet on its LAN. Hopefully you don't have this issue.