Thank you! I wish I could give you a hundred thumbs up for that. Great advice! I'm going to use your method for sure.
I'm still somewhat confused by the memory and disk space. I'm sure there's a very valid reason for it, but I don't understand why so much space is allocated to temp, leaving only 80MB. I guess this will be enough but ideally, I'd like to keep plenty of space free for other packages etc.
Regarding your specific disk space it is most likely down to how OpenWrt partitions its space for your particular router. Without knowing more about it i cant guess further than that. My router uses a sdcard so i'm using a 32gb card so i dont need to worry about disk space. I also run my ubiquiti cloud manager from a docker container on the router.
Regarding AGH? The space requirements used to be smaller but the 107 build introduced a fair bit of extra space used (its down to the Go Librarys they updated. They are looking into it and one way to get the space down is to compress it and let the cpu decompress on the fly.
There is an issue filed on it and last i checked it was to be dealt with as part of the 108 builds but my guess is they probably pushed it back to the 109 build.
The reason for double space usage is when AGH upgrades it copies your existing binary and setup files into a backup folder. Then it installs over the top of the main binary and restarts. I have a manual script (that you need to edit depending on your cpu type) that will upgrade in place and I've asked the developers about it and it is part of their refactoring of the codebase but is still not completed yet. (AGH tends to silently fail doing an update with no disk space left. It does complain in the logs but the interface just reports "Failed". I've asked them to do some simple disk space checks but that then circles around back to how much space they use which they are trying to reduce. Right now there is no "simple" way they can say "we use X space. Check thats free") (edit - found it - https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome/issues/3801)
Your logs can be controlled by keeping them to 30days or so. or even a week if u just want minimal logs. Statistics can be 90days as the main db for that isn't huge. Sadly i just reset all my logs and stats this week trying to hunt down some adverts slipping past my filters so i cant give you some longer term log sizes.
Wow. Thank you for taking the time with such a detailed and well coorindated reply. I really do appreciate it!
Haha, not likely anytime soon! Are you running on a Pi?
I'd be ok with keeping the logs for 7 days or so, given my limited space. I guess I'll just have to experiment with it. Your method is definitely better, because of course I had the issue if the logs clearing every time I rebooted.
I'm all over this link! I'll most certainly be keeping a close eye on it. Thank you!
I'll have another go at installing AdGuard over the weekend and let you know how I get on. Out of interest, do you use the default filter lists or is there any extra you'd recommend? Thanks again and sorry about all the questions!
You are welcome. I took about 3 threads on the forum including a massive 2yr long one and with some further research and testing (along with some help from a few others), turned all that into my master thread. From those efforts and some help from @jamesmacwhite a wiki was sorted out and finally an opkg version properly sorted. (the 104 edition of agh was... really bad.) That's one reason why i re-wrote everything and got it to a more useable state, plus feedback to AGH team with issues too. Part of it is i think they were surprised at how AGH was being used on much smaller routers etc. They were used to people using x86 routers or even mini pcs where space and memory isnt constrained but building into soho routers takes much more care and planning. (like how my manual version vs opkg version differ due to space and usage).
Nope. Something rather more fun. a NanoPi R4S : NanoPi R4S rk3399 4G is a great new OpenWrt device
That plugs into a local lan switch (I really want a ubiquiti POE one but getting one is damn near impossible right now) and then a separate POE powered Ubiquiti AC-Lite for my wifi due to my insane concreate walls that make wifi damn near impossible.
It shouldn't be a major issue. I haven't rebooted mine in a while.
But yes, loosing the logs can be a pain. For most people however its not too bad an issue. If you have the space however, then the manual version where you can keep all the logs etc is much nicer.
No problem on questions. Drop a post in the thread if you run into issues. That's what its there for.
As for filters... that's bit more tricky. I was using a custom set and i did publish them but AGH team redid a fair few of them and now the ones they come with are pretty good. There are one or two i wouldn't use and i also use a few different ones from the custom ones just purely down to my choices. But for completeness i'll list you the filters part from my yaml file.
I'd suggest you just copy the name of the list and its location into the AGH interface by doing a manual list unless you are confident at editing yaml files. Even an extra space will make it barf up with config errors. (trust me... done it myself and its a pain.)
The whitelist one is quite important. Anudeep also lists a couple of other ones in case the wife likes shopping sites etc. That enables referral links etc.
AdAway Default Blocklist and Dandelion Sprout's Anti-Malware List i disabled due to some issues. I may have to check it out again at some point but the rest were ok. However his Smart TV blocker is wonderful.
What i do caution for filters is this. Start small, look at what is going on in your network, don't just add 2million filters and then wonder why your router is on fire. Its also another reason i removed my personal lists and tell people to start with the default ones the AGH team update internally.
(edit) Once you have your family filtering done and working, please feel free to document it in a post on the thread. I don't use family filtering and dont have a lot of other devices to do that kind of testing with. I'm sure others will be in your situation of requiring filtering and monitoring of the little ones and would appreciate your experience of setup etc. I could then add relevant bits to the wiki as well for others to use. #themoreyouknow
Thanks again for all the great help! I'll definitely get to it as soon as I sort out a couple of other issues first. My IPTV needs sorted and some issues with DDNS. I'm sure I'll get there in the end though. I'll update here when I get AGH up and running
Quick question, need to know the specific release branch and router targets people are using if the builds are failing on certain router architectures. I've poked james about it and if we can get more info we can do some investigations.
There was some foresight it might be a problem: https://github.com/openwrt/packages/issues/17508, its likely because AdGuardHome doesn't like being built with a different version of Go. Currently 0.107 stable releases require 1.17, but now OpenWrt is using 1.18 in master, which might explain the failure.
It seems that maybe things might just about to get even easier. Looking at the pictures in those blogs, this appears to be a much more polished version of AGH. With better stats and parental controls. Its in beta right now but I'm rather curious as to how it will compare against AGH currently. I definatly want those stats pages etc. And I'm fairly sure the more polished parental controls would be a must for others.
Thank! Haha yes that's exactly what I'm looking for
I've decided to ditch the Belkin RT3200 as my main router. I'm having far too many issues trying to get it working properly. I've spent so many hours trying to get seemingly basic things working and as soon as I change one thing, something else breaks. I'm sure this is mostly caused by me, but other issues, such as the firewall time rules working, then for no reason not working? I can't get my head around it. I think what I'm going to do now is what I should have done a long time ago. Use my server which I have on 24x7 connected directly to my router for AGH. I will probably use my other OpenWRT router (Xiaomi Mi 4A Gigabit) as an access point and go from there.
The final straw for me witht the RT3200 was trying to get my IPTV to work with OpenWRT. I tried all the settings I could find, and ended up bricking the unit again. I did manage to recover it but again, I had issues with restoring from backup. I might try again when there is a stable release for the RT3200.
I've already spent many hours with igmpproxy and the changes either didn't work, or it broke other things and ended up bricking my router completely. I fully admit that this could have been something I did, but to the best of my knowledge, I was at least careful and don't recall breaking anything obvious.
I'm certainly not giving up on OpenWRT. I think I will use my lower powered Mi 4A Gigabit router seeing as I am going to run AGH from my server instead, so don't really need the extra space etc. I may just use it as an OpenWRT access point. I'm not sure yet! I'm going on a break in a few days' time, so will no doubt start poking around with OpenWRT again when I return
if you want more logging to see what's happening. put the verbose to 3 and restart it. Then you can see everything going on and just reduce it down to 1 once you have it working.
dont forget option igmp_snooping 1 on your lan bridge thou.
option quickleave 1
# option verbose [0-3](none, minimal[default], more, maximum)
option verbose 1
option network wan
option zone wan
option direction upstream
list altnet 0.0.0.0/0 # allow everything
option network lan
option zone lan
option direction downstream