It seems that MT7621's HW OFFLOAD break the network under latest snapshot. I can ping from LAN to WAN, but can not open websites.
It happens under latest snapshot and 19.07 snapshot, 18.06.4 works well.
Resurrecting this old thread because it's pretty impossible to figure out what's the current status (wiki page needed?).
My RBM33G (MT7621) takes advantage of flow offloading on OpenWrt 19.07.4, r11208-ce6496d796; I get 10-15% more performance (eyes-measure, no exact methodology, no benchmarks). What about other platforms? (if any)
ar71xx - ???
ar79 - ???
mipsel - ???
mt7621 minor improvements and using vlans with hw offlload enabled breaks.
So not really usable, plus the latest openwrt using 5.4 has no hw offload currently.
Really ?! I didn't test properly, but I noticed 10-15% less soft irqs (using top) when flow offloading was enabled. I couldn't notice any difference using sw or hw offloading, but something was happening.
Ehm, is it a definitive feature drop, or temporary lack of flow offloading given the kernel version bump?
ar71xx/ath79: with software flow offload, a TP-Link Archer C7 goes from 250 Mbps to 700 Mbps, but all instances of software-based flow offload currently break long-lived idle TCP connections. The timeout is for some reason always 120s (and ignores the
net.netfilter.nf_conntrack_tcp_timeout_established sysctl value), see Software flow offloading and conntrack timeouts for a more detailed report.
It was added back to work with DSA. On MT7622 it can do 940 mbps NAT over PPPoE at 0% CPU load.
"On MT7622" - on which router exactly?
Tested on Banana Pi R64
I don't think MT7622 is a good measure if flow offload working better or not
ARM Cortex A53 is too fast a CPU to detect much changes in performance.
I am testing flow offload on MT7621 and seems to be stucked at 700-800Mbps
It's definitively visible, on sirq.
Without flow offload:
CPU: 0% usr 0% sys 0% nic 56% idle 0% io 0% irq 43% sirq
With flow offload:
CPU: 0% usr 0% sys 0% nic 99% idle 0% io 0% irq 0% sirq
How did you get that? Zero sirq!?
EDIT: the following tests aren't useful as I was running iperf on the router. They only show that sw offloading is working, but can't say anything about hw offloading.
My RBM33G have some benefit but still gets most of sirq and sys when hw offloading is enabled:
Mem: 67660K used, 186060K free, 1544K shrd, 1732K buff, 16228K cached CPU: 0% usr 25% sys 0% nic 37% idle 0% io 0% irq 36% sirq Load average: 1.18 0.40 0.13 4/87 18703 PID PPID USER STAT VSZ %VSZ %CPU COMMAND 18694 18685 root R 1148 0% 25% iperf3 -s
[ 5] 0.00-94.00 sec 7.99 GBytes 730 Mbits/sec 4 sender
Sw offload gives better throughput and higher cpu usage.
Mem: 54752K used, 198968K free, 236K shrd, 1588K buff, 10140K cached CPU: 1% usr 25% sys 0% nic 29% idle 0% io 0% irq 43% sirq Load average: 0.94 0.50 0.21 3/93 3205 PID PPID USER STAT VSZ %VSZ %CPU COMMAND 3205 3196 root R 1136 0% 25% iperf3 -s
[ 5] 0.00-205.90 sec 21.5 GBytes 898 Mbits/sec 70 sender
No offload gives worst throughput and cpu usage:
Mem: 55576K used, 198144K free, 236K shrd, 1588K buff, 10104K cached CPU: 0% usr 26% sys 0% nic 43% idle 0% io 0% irq 29% sirq Load average: 0.72 0.40 0.19 4/93 3225 PID PPID USER STAT VSZ %VSZ %CPU COMMAND 3215 3207 root R 1132 0% 25% iperf3 -s
[ 5] 0.00-255.19 sec 20.7 GBytes 697 Mbits/sec 79 sender
Note: OpenWrt 19.07.4, r11208-ce6496d796. I rebooted between one test and the other. Iperf client is gbit ethernet connected directly to one of the rbm33g ethernet ports; the 3 ports are separated using vlans.
Do not run iperf3 on your router. Flow offloading does not work that way.
His router has a ARM Cortex A53 core, our MT7621ATs are MIPS1004Kc
I am getting the same numbers as you but the thing is I have seen better numbers on MT7621 before this where 1Gbps Throughput works so I am not sure what caused the regression.
I run jperf standalone client/server
BTW, MIPS1004Kc? I'm using MIPS24Kc binaries! Should I switch to MIPS1004Kc?
Doesn't matter Openwrt label them MIPS24kc but the binaries are MIPS32R2 so they are compatible
Ok, to recap:
- the MT7621 is partly broken in 19.07.4 but works in trunk thanks to nbd's feature rewrite.
- ARM Cortex A53 is working.
- ... ?
What about ar71/ar79? There are a ton of atheros/qualcom devices out there! On the Mikrotik HAP AC (ar71xx) was not working at all; even sw offloading.
Hardware Flow Offloading only works on Mediatek SoC (for example MT7621) and as far as I know, only on 19.07.4 or 19.07-snapshot (also in old versions of 18.06.x), not in 5.4 kernel. Sirq usage should be 0% and give speeds of over 900Mbps.
It's working correctly? I am currently on 19.07.4 but I still have not been able to test it because I use vpn policy routing and it seems to give problems with more than one routing table.
With Software Flow Offloading you get faster speeds with less CPU usage than without it. As far as I know, it doesn't give any problem.
ok, cool missed that one.