Home network hardware help please?

I have a mess I'm trying to clean up and would love some help please. Currently in use are a Starlink router in bypass mode with a hub and an old Ubiquity Unifi mesh router that's incompatible with OpenWrt. 5000 square feet of coverage needed. Price isn't nearly as important as function. More than willing to pay for quality and function, but don't want to throw money away. Have a 2.4 printer, but happy to ditch that if needed.

Will run VPN on the router. Wired and wireless connections.12 Ports on the switch/hub at a minimum. Very out of the loop on current offerings and my knowledge is fairly antiquated. Trying to get back up to speed. Also if I'm going to buy used equipment online are issues with that going to show up in the OpenWrt load or is looking in the case a good idea just in case someone might have included a gift? Thank you.

How many floors?

Single story.

Roughly one router per 1000-2000sqft, ie at least 3 optimally positioned and wired up.
What internet connection technology you expect? Say for 2Gbps DOCSIS it would be better to have separate device fighting network latency and cheap(er) routers as extenders.

Basic setup (gigabit to end devices, all access points wired)
Flint 2 (gl.inet mt6000) for "first" device
Cudy WR3000? or GL-MT3000 for extenders.

All have spare ports to sum up for all devices, but otherwise any somewhat manageable 2.5Gbps switch will do

Maximum - main router https://store.minisforum.com/products/minisforum-ms-01 , then flint2 (or leave some spaces vacant and in 1-2 years get additional wifi7 devies)

Also among planning - if you buy from same vendor and they allow for no-cloud local configuration of mixed mesh you can stay with that, though after 2-5yrs OpenWrt compatibility will become handy.

(not implying anything, buy OpenWrt compatible devices, link mixed mesh with batman software) but dont buy mesh pucks thinking they are good for coverage https://www.asus.com/microsite/AiMesh//en/index.html

? among possibilities devices with multiple 5ghz radios for over the air mesh ?

2.4GHz is not a problem, in worst case you add separate access point near it with reduced cryptography strength.....

If APs are wired, and you're in US, SAX1V1K's on eBay, they're $30/pcs.

Router, x86 something, Dell Edge 620's are around $50, also on eBay.

Out of pure curiosity, do you have any visibility into the compatibility of related models (SAX1V1S, SAX1V1R)?

A couple of options per device type:

[router]
NanoPi R6C
Radxa E52C

[managed PoE switch (OEM firmware)]
Netgear GS316EP
Ubiquiti Pro Max 16 PoE
ZyXEL GS1915-24EP

[Wi-Fi PoE access points indoor]
Cudy AP3000
Netgear WAX220
Ubiquiti UniFi U6+
Zyxel NWA50AX Pro

[Wi-Fi PoE access points outdoor]
Cudy AP3000 Outdoor
Zyxel NWA55AXE

note: for initial setup of PoE powered access points use a PoE splitter or spare PoE switch

1 Like

S is Broadcom, AFAIK - SAX1V1S / Sagemcom
R is supposed to be the same as K - Spectrum SAX1V1K (Askey RT5010W) OpenWrt Support - #133 by kino0924

1 Like

Thanks everyone. I'm going to look into all these suggestions and see what I can come up with. A bit out of my depth, but if that's what it takes.

are the APs wired or wireless ?

the latter would imply tri radio devices - "tri band" (triple interface) router list.

1 Like

As a way of update I was able to install OpenWrt on a Unify 6+ without any issues other than the unfamiliarity with everything. I don't really know how the Unify was setup before, but guessing I can set this up as wireless with the Starlink in bypass until I move further. Seems like it could be bridged, but some device has to be doing the work. Thanks!

Thanks for the link. Still figuring it out. Could be either really.

You really don't want them to be wireless, if wired is an option.

1 Like

Using the OEM firmware on the switch is not an issue as far as privacy/control? I can't see any oem firmware becoming less invasive as time goes on. I would be like the chimpanzees in 2001 dancing around the monolith with a managed switch though, at least initially.

Definitely want to separate guest access and not have everything bleed over as it does now. Any favorites among your recommendations? Found the beginner's guide you wrote, very helpful.

If you list old equipmemt you may use we can rank that too by suitability to your setup and OpenWrt

Starlink router. Ubiquity Unify 6+. 8PGIGUN unmanaged switch. That's it for now. My plan is to run the Starllink in bypass (interesting that it took itself out of bypass mode when the 6+ was removed (thanks E). VPN and Adblock on the router or other device if needed and switch and a couple of access points. Just need to buy the switch, access points and router. Also will likely duplicate the router, switch and one access point to run on the side so I can learn/test on, get familiar without disrupting anything. Initially just want to reign everything in. VPN on the router, adblock, guest access separate and want to block all these appliances trying to phone home.

Also need to find a printer that doesn't harvest data, but likely have to buy an old one. My wife would never go for cabled printing so another research project.

don't connect the printer to the LAN ?
if it got USB port or LPT port, hook it up to a used print server (again, ebay) or router with USB port.
print via the print server/router instead of directly to the printer.

1 Like

The Zyxel GS1900-24HP is a good candidate for an OpenWrt-firmware capable switch.

1 Like

Also (very high end switches) https://vyos.io/hcl no tracking, can run OpenWrt if you install it

You can run a print server on OpenWrt with USB port.

1 Like

The Radza E52C isn't currently available in 8gb ram. 4gb 32emmc is available. Is 4 adequate for vpn, adblock?