Xbox LIVE always Moderate NAT?

[Jack007]

Just a thought; what happens if you temporarily enable upnp? Do you get an open-nat then?

Are you aware of this thread:

UPnP port forwarding not working for Windows 10 and Xbox One

I can't get UPnP port forwarding to work properly with Windows 10 or Xbox and OpenWrt 19.07.6 on x86. Torrenting apps and basic UPnP test programs such as UPnP Wizard work fine, as does Demonware (e.g. for Call of Duty on the Xbox), but UPnP is not working for Xbox live in Windows 10 and on the Xbox - the port forwards never appear in the list of leases. I've only become aware of this recently, so I'm not sure exactly when it broke, but it was definitely working with miniupnpd 2.1 in 18.0.6 be…