And I have not any Transmission on the 1st router.
In general I have not the solution for the problem with Transmission running on LEDE routers. I am looking for it as many users do.
EDIT: Sorry for the disappointment, glad that I made you happy for some moments!
If you are certain that you have made the correct forward rule on the first LEDE device, and input rule on the second LEDE device, (from device 2) please provide an output of:
People who have the upload port problem, which daemon have you installed, transmission-daemon-mbedtls or transmission-daemon-openssl?
I cannot answer my own question because now I have reinstalled LEDE for another reason and I don't remember which daemon I installed before.
Before I had transmission-daemon-mbedtls and the upload port was closed, no upload speed appeared at Transmission remote GUI.
Then I tried transmission-daemon-openssl with the same result.
I removed Transmission.
I have this same problem. I am running transmission-daemon-openssl on the router. I have no problems downloading but seeding and connecting to peers seems to struggle compared to my computer.
I tried following this guide but it got me nowhere:
At the github bug-report link above neheb says that he has solved the Transmission port misfunction for OpenWRT! https://github.com/openwrt/packages/issues/5459
If someone here can post the exact solution for LEDE following neheb's instructions it would be perfect, I want very much to install again Transmission in my LEDE router!
Vasilis, Transmission is fine even now, only the reporting whether the port is open is broken - receiveing and sending files is ok (you still have to open the port in the firewall and then check with some external tool if it is open) so you can install transmission even now.
@felagund I understand, but I thought I should mention the bug-work here, because I have not yet reinstalled Transmission and I don't remember if the Transmission remote GUI reports the upload rate of a torrent file/folder. In any case Transmission reporting the port open or closed is of some importance and it's also the title of this thread.
I'm having this problem with the latest OpenWRT. I run transmission-daemon-openssl direct from my router. Here are my port forwarding settings. What am I doing wrong?
Edit - I changed from any host in wan to from any host in lan and it still doesn't work.
I also installed the unpnp service but no dice there also.
I noticed that even despite having upnp installed transmission is not passing the correct port forwarding information automatically:
Could using upnp possibly fix this for good?
[2018-08-07 18:34:45.827] Port Forwarding (UPnP) UPNP_GetValidIGD failed (errno 0 - No error information) (upnp.c:239)
[2018-08-07 18:34:45.827] Port Forwarding (UPnP) If your router supports UPnP, please make sure UPnP is enabled! (upnp.c:242)
[2018-08-07 18:34:45.827] Port Forwarding Starting (port-forwarding.c:92)