[SOLVED] Anyone having issues with QoS App?

Installing and Using OpenWrt
1

Running OpenWrt 18.06-SNAPSHOT r7013-f18f08d.

After installing QoS, I noticed that some entries do not populate my fw3.

I've noticed some patterns:

  • if the SRC or DST host is a CIDR range, it does not appear
  • if ALL is specified without ports, it does not appear
  • SRC and DST IPs are sometimes "truncated"

For the "truncating" example, this rule:

config classify                      
        option target 'Bulk'          
        option proto 'tcp'           
        option ports '10000'           
        option comment 'Webmin'                   
        option srchost '192.168.x.5'             
        option dsthost '192.168.y.5'

Creates:


0 	0.00 B 	MARK 	tcp 	* 	* 	0.0.0.0/0 	192.168.y.5 	mark match 0x0/0xf /* Webmin */ MARK xset 0x44/0xff

(Notice the source address is missing.)

Example 2
The following 2 configs now result in no rules being created:

config classify                                   
        option proto 'udp'                           
        option comment 'Multicast'                   
        option dsthost '224.0.0.0/4'             
        option target 'Bulk'

config classify                        
        option target 'Bulk'            
        option proto 'tcp'             
        option ports '10000'                      
        option comment 'Webmin'

Any ideas?

2

Could you try PR#1044 and report your findings here/there? It might be related to your issue.

EDIT: Updated the PR, so please reconfirm if this fixes the problem.

1 Like
3

My issue is not fixed. In fact, I now have 0 QoS rules. I don't see a QoS firewall chain, either.

  • LuCI Master (git-18.176.34901-0d9a64b) / OpenWrt SNAPSHOT r7333-1b46bce
  • luci-app-qos git-18.176.34901-0d9a64b-1
4

The fix is in PR#1044 as noted before, which has been tested by a few users but is not merged yet. Are you using the version from the PR, or just a more recent master snapshot? Doing the latter won't change anything unfortunately.

If you are testing the PR and found a problem, you can help by posting your findings and your UCI config file in either PR#1044 or the recent bug at FS#1602.

But from your description it's not clear to me that you're testing the fix.

5

Fixed in LuCI Master (git-18.179.27825-485e5c9) / OpenWrt SNAPSHOT r7357-4456dd4

Commit b701d78105a3f233f993dddde12d16973ba88972 fixed the issue and was added to master.