Since I'm currently using some pretty old network devices and the Wi-Fi coverage is no longer sufficient for my new robotic lawn mower and need some upgrades. I'm now planning to completely rebuild my network, which is something I'd actually been planning to do for a long time, but never managed to get started on. Since the range of devices available is rather overwhelming, and I'm not entirely sure what to look for in detail, I'd appreciate any recommendations and advices.
My Requirements:
My internet connection is 1Gbit (mostly synced with 1.1 or 1.2Gbit) via coax cable, but I will use a fitting cable modem. So the router would simply need a wan port with at least 2.5Gbit.
Wi-Fi should support 2.4Ghz and 5Ghz and 6Ghz is optional. So I would prefer a tri-band or quad-band router. The feature to host 2 isolated Wi-Fi networks would be great, since I want to split my network into two subnets. But this should be also possible by using an additional access point which creates the second Wi-Fi network. The second Wi-Fi has to support at least 2.4Ghz and an additional 5Ghz would be great but is optional. External adjustable antennas are preferred to hopefully reduce the number of needed repeaters.
An additional ethernet port with at least 2.5Gbit should exist to use my only non Wi-Fi connected device. More ethernet ports are not needed since this could be extended by a switch later.
Since I would rather use a home server instead sharing files via the router, a USB port is completely optional and not needed.
The ethernet port and one Wi-Fi should support communicating between devices and would need support for 5-10 devices. The second Wi-Fi need to support an additional 5-10 devices. Not completely sure but I think less would be ok since devices like sensors or the robot mower should be fine with transmitting separately in sequence and need no fast network connection. Actual human users would be one for the first Wi-Fi which is combined with the ethernet connections. And the other second Wi-Fi would have 2 regular users as well as some random guests
The isolated second Wi-Fi need VPN so the router/ additional AP should support WireGuard and OpenVPN protocol.
The router should fully support OpenWrt with complete FOSS firmware and no proprietary software blobs.
For the price range, it would be nice to not go much higher than €200/ $200 (just assume same value for euro or dollar since the US and EU market would differ anyway.) But please feel free to suggest more expensive devices as well if you think they're a better fit for my needs. Ultimately, price isn't a major factor, and I'd be willing to spend up to €400/$400 if it offers a benefit that makes sense to me.
If the suggested router can only host one Wi-Fi please bundle the suggestion with a fitting access point for the second Wi-Fi, if possible.
In addition I think I will need some Wi-Fi repeater to reach my whole garden, but I would like to focus on the router (and if needed the AP for the second Wi-Fi) at first. After I have the router running I would look for the coverage and plan the needed repeater in a second step.
I would prefer support for multiuser MIMO with possibility for beamforming.
Finally I don't need a device that allows for a simple OpenWrt installation. As a trained computer scientist, I should be able to handle even a complex manual flashing process.
If anyone already has experience with a DIY OpenWrt router or has a link to a relevant post or article, please feel free to share it. Depending on the cost and effort involved, this could definitely be an exciting project and an interesting alternative. Just please no Raspberry Pi-based solutions, but rather something that can be easily expanded in the future, such as an HTPC with enough PCIe lanes to later add new Wi-Fi standards or faster Ethernet ports.
I'd like to thank you in advance for reading as well as for your suggestions and feedback.
Let's work on the plan first:
You want Wi-Fi outside and isolated (vlan).
To do that, you decided to do it all.
Wifi outside will attract everyone that is bored, so that AP requires WPA3.
You do not want to broadcast any more than necessary or in any direction you wont use, so one of the directional type of antenna.
You will not cover the yard with WiFi, unless you put antennas outside, or a flat antenna on an outside wall, facing the yard.
Presume you have a back yard.(?) Now we need to move the antenna to up high and point down
or
another AP.
Sorry, it seems my explanation was not specific enough.
First Wi-Fi combined with the ethernet should be my private network for my devices only like not proprietary smart home devices under my full control. This Wi-Fi is only needed inside the house except one device in one specific direction. For this the router itself could be enough.
The second one is for family members, their proprietary smart home devices and visitors. Since I do not control these devices and not want them inside my network. This one need to reach the whole garden because of the robot mower. Since the house lies pretty much in the middle of the property a good positioning and better antennas as my actual router could maybe reach the most areas.
I actually use a Fritzbox 6591 with one repeater. With my phone I can use the Wi-Fi on the entire property with at least about 10Mbit, but the mower seems to not have the best Wi-Fi hardware and cannot reach it on the entire property. With the new hardware a better positioning will be possible. There is no longer a requirement to be within a maximum of 3 meters of the network connection box, which is sadly directly at one corner of my house. For the new setup, this requirement applies only to the modem, and the network cable between the modem and the router can be significantly longer. This is why I want to get router plus maybe a second Access Point for the second Wi-Fi to test it before looking where an additional repeater is needed.
My question if I require another device for the second Wi-Fi bases on my actual router, which is capable to host 2 entirely isolated Wi-Fi networks each with both 2.4 and 5Ghz. The second one is designed as a guest Wi-Fi and is restricted to fewer settings, but the router can host 2 by itself. This function is not needed, and a second device is ok too, but it would be nice if there is a router which is capable doing this.
So the first question belongs only to the router and an additional Access Point to host the second Wi-Fi if needed. So the question if I can reach the whole property with the signal can be ignored for now, and I want to check this when the new router (+ AP) is running. WPA3 has been around for so long now that I expected it to be supported on new devices. But yes, it makes sense to clarify that.
Here you have a problem, if someone doesn't correct me, both atheros and mediatek firmwares are not FOSS (perhaps except old ath9k). I remember to read that mediatek is the one with the less proprietary bytes. Anyway if you look at linux-firmware has many non FOSS firmware that at least the license allow redistribution. I think like you but actually is impossible or nearly to achieve that goal.
I had the mower in mind the whole time: I do not want to take any chance it could lose signal.
Worst thing would be when we get to the lawn mower and need adjustment. I am firm that I believe the lawn mower signal should be very seriously prioritized part the of the plan.
Let me un fixate on the mower part for a few while other's join.
Thanks, I absolutely did not think about the mostly closed firmware of modern chips. This is very sad.
So it's an equal problem like with smartphones (at least most or may all) using custom ROMs but need to use proprietary firmware for some chips like 5g?
Then there's the option of building it entirely from scratch, but you probably wouldn't be able to find complete FOSS firmware for things like the Wi-Fi chip.
Or actually, if I think about it more carefully, the problems start right there with the UEFI and the motherboard firmware in general, or am I wrong?
Yes, that is. But even I also have same concern about having all FOSS if possible, I match with @LilRedDog. Most part of mediatek wifi is FOSS, I think for you better suit that point, but, I think you shouldn't close yourself if there is Atheros router that fits better your use case.
Sure, since I have to live with this problems on my smartphone and PC as well, so I could take it if needed. I only had the hope full FOSS is possible, which I happily would support, even they are more expensive.
But ok, feels a bit sad but it's not dramatic.
Thanks for your recommendations @howl@LilRedDog@cookiemonster. I will look into them when I find the time for it, but maybe I won't find time until tomorrow.
On my conspiracy side:
I find it odd the thermometer/hygrometer has bluetooth and beacons, but there is no supporting software.
What is it looking for?
Well, if I wanted to sneak in an attack, and everything has Bluetooth these days, I'd have devices listen for a shut down/blow-fuse command.
I have quite the imagination and a little knowledge.
I finally found the time to look through your suggestions and identify some devices that I think would be suitable.
However, I have to admit that I’m actually starting to favor building my own router after talking to a coworker who went down that route.
The main question here would be if OpenWrt supports two 2,4Ghz Wi-Fi Networks when using two separate Wi-Fi Chips.
I’ll keep you updated on what I decide.
If I do decide to build my own and there’s interest, I’d be happy to document the process in the appropriate subsection.