Is the Linksys E8450 right for my use case?

Hi, I'm a guy who is going to have some free time in the coming weeks. So, I've decided to improve my home networking.

I've gotten myself an old machine to set up OPNsense and have been considering an OpenWRT WAP. The reasons (for wanting an OpenWRT WAP) are as follows:

  1. I like the philosophy behind FOSS software.
  2. Though a management VLAN can eliminate much of the attack surface of a WAP, I still feel more comfortable with the privsec of a frequently updated FOSS project like OpenWRT.

For this, I've found a couple Linksys E8450 in the $10-15 buck range. Is this a good OpenWRT system? My needs are just to have WiFi speeds sufficient for a 5 room (1 floor) apartment of 5 'normal' users. By 'normal', I just mean the average joe who installs Android/desktop apps every now and then, stream media, watch social media, etc over WiFi.

From what I've seen online, the E8450 shouldn't have any glaring issues for my purposes? The only issues are

  1. The UBI installation is slightly more complicated than some other OpenWRT-compatible routers/WAPs. But, I think it should be fine as long as I read and follow the docs carefully enough.
  2. OpenWrt Kiss of Death (OKD), already fixed.

It seems to me that I should be good to go with an E8450, but the $10-15 feels too good to be true lol. So, I wanted to be prudent and check here before I purchase anything. Feel free to correct me if I said anything wrong, cheers.

E8450 feels outdated today, but it'll get the job done.

I'd add $10 and get a SAX1V1K, or add another $20 and get a W1700k or SBE1V1K, all from eBay.

The SAX1V1K and w1700k require serial to be flashed though.

The only one I could find (I checked multiple platforms) was the Spectrum SAX1V1K on eBay. Unfortunately, because I live in Asia, the shipping would be multiple times the price of the SAX1V1K itself.

You probably should have mentioned it in the 1st post, quoting in USD didn't help.

There's a similar device to the w1700k in Asia called Brightspeed XR1710G, it however not support yet, and the PR seems stuck.

Hm I think that's also a bit niche; I couldn't find it anywhere. Do you have any suggestions that are more widespread, like WAPs from TP-Link, ASUS, Linksys, etc?

Pretty much any device from this folder will do, cross reference with your local market.

For that price I would not let the E8450 go given your use case. If the network routing and so is going to be done by OPNsense you don't need so much horsepower and still E8450 has a considerable one, not as much as actual filogic ones but given your use case I think doesn't mind.

Another thing is how you are going to do the backhaul, wired or wireless. If it's wired is one more point to consider the E8450. I have 3 E8450 with mesh backhaul and nowadays if I want to upgrade I will go at least for triband routers to leave a radio only for the mesh or change to wired the three E8450.

The installation is very easy being the most disturbing step the need to use a old browser because the stock login fails with modern ones. Is possible to bring up Internet Explorer in actual Windows by just running a command anyway.

The OKD was fixed yes, (I didn't suffer it, as a hit of luck I had mines stopped that period).

My final recommendation is that only in the future you plan to substitute OPNsense with OpenWrt in the routers to manage the WAN take into account more recent and powerful routers, at least the main one.

I see, thanks! I'm going to do a wired backhaul since ethernet outlets are already been wired into my wall.

Forget to mention, one think people overlook is that the E8450 is N for the 2.4 GHz radio instead AX. The 5 GHz is AX. I don't know if that is important to you but I think it's worth knowing.

Oh, thanks for letting me know. I guess I can try nabbing another one for $15 if I need to; there are 3 in the $10-15 range currently.

https://toh.openwrt.org/ + cpu filter MT798

I use a Belkin RT3200 (same as E8450) as an AP on the second floor of our home with just one wall between it and the other rooms. I'd pay $15 for it today for the same use. It's WiFi performance is quite good for internal antennas.

None of our 2.4 GHz clients need much throughput, so lack of ax on 2.4 GHz hasn't been an issue.