HW selection 2024 vs OpenWRT One

Hello,

Iam currently using opnsense and suffer with issues, after upgrades and now even crashes on high traffic. After learning a lot, I want to change now to OpenWRT, as should be enough for my demand at home and hopefully more stable.

My demand

  • Basic Firewall rules for some VLANs
  • Wireguard
  • DynDNS
  • DNS via quad9
  • Adguard (like more than PIHole)
  • 2,5GB Ethernet would be nice, WAN 1GB is fine
  • WLAN optional, if WIFI 6E or 7 nice as adone
  • Low Power consumption

WIFI is covered with TP-Link Omada runnning and Omada server on a proxmox...

That basically already all, so I assumevnot high HW requirement but would like to run the latest and good HW if cost are below 200 EUR. Is here OpenWRT One - the best option currently beside long shipping? Started to play around on small N100 I had here but I assume even to much...
Adding OMV functionality or similar are also nice to have but not mandatory. Most of my stuff is running on Proxmox server...

Many Thanks in advance!

These? Adguardhome will need more than gigabyte RAM, no wifi7 devices yet, rest is within abilities of minimal cheap router, vpn speed depends on CPU - 100Mbps on 7621, >500Mbps on qualcommax filogic.

https://openwrt.org/toh/views/toh_available_16128_ax-wifi

1 Like

They bumped up the price by 10€, bastards.
Same SoC as the One.

1 Like

they raised the price because you write about this model everywhere :slight_smile: Cheap routers like silence. Where am I going to buy another 10 pieces now :slight_smile:

4 Likes

It's well worth the attention, imho.

First rule of Fight club...

3 Likes

Hello,

many thanks I thing will go for MT7986A (Filogic 830) as processor, to have long term ressource buffer.
The GL.iNet GL-MT6000(Flint 2) , OpenWRT one seem in my focus for reviewing now. Zyxel T56 seem very price attractive alternativ. Need to check on drawback... 40 EUR / 120 EUR / 140 EUR...

PITA to flash.

1 Like

As shipping for Flint2 is 24h and minor discount currently, will go first with this.
Still like more DYI Design of OpenWRT One, but if thing missing can still order later... So looking forward to get closer in OpenWRT SW and get my basic function running, and see that I find no gaps vs opnsense of today and reduce my overhead of failures as of today...

Regarding installed firmware, if seems that they also used openWRT, but GUI is provided selected functionality in slightly more modern design.
Would you recommend to switch directly to or can I access both ? (WIKI: LUCI is also available for power users.)

No, they used an Openwrt based vendor SDK.

No router I've ever owned, have had the stock fw installed longer than 5 mins.

1 Like

Well also my tendency but good to hear that no the wrong step :smiley:
Many thanks for support, than I can start now to check logic/config for firewall....

I thought the One was MT7981 (1.3 Ghz) and the T56 was the MT7986 (2 Ghz)?

But yeah I have the EX5601 and it's really great with OpenWRT plus uboot.

how about a Nanopi R4S? or R46 with snapshot/rc?

Get a N100 mini pc.

all-band wifi6e will break the bank by n100 bucks alrwdy

It's optional for op.

Here's what I gathered so far:

T56 is hard to flash, through serial pins? has no poe and alot of router circuitry like voip / switch etc that presumably eats power.

Openwrt One is expensive, but is passively cooled, supports poe (and an m2 ssd m2 2230 2242 keyM )

Beryl AX (glinet 3000) is very cute comparable to the Openwrt one, but it has active cooling (fan) and no poe

glinet 6000 (flint2) is double the throughput power of the 3000, has a higher poweruse and no poe power supply function , (its overkill for my usage)
if you rely heavily on wifi it may be one of the best APs out there now

I'm thinking of buying an openwrt one since I plan to mainly use it as a poe fed AP

Hard would be a little harsh, but it requires more knowledge than the MT6000 for sure.

https://openwrt.org/toh/zyxel/t-56

If you already have a device capable to install OPNsense, then most likely you can use that to install OpenWrt, however you'd probably need to check the stability since you've mentioned crashing.

OMG, after the GL.inet Flint2 arrived today everything works like a sharm!
Firmware update auf Sysupgrade & go.

Coming form Opnsense and spending lot time on tutorials - unbelievable how simple it can be! No only Wireguard need to be installed and all is done.

Thanks again for tips, should have switch much ealier :partying_face:

2 Likes

lol this is unbelievable
outside NL the EX5601 is around 90-100€, i'd get one of these YESTERDAY just to have fun flashing it :slight_smile:

Edit: ok i see it has no SFP port, still a great value for money!