Fiber optic vs VDSL2 connexion

hi everybody optical fiber 1/go

my brother has a 1gb/600 fiber optic no matter what i do his connection is slow, i tried qosify and sqm with nftables rules

but nothing works,

I lowered his connection to 400/400 or 350 /350 since the rt3200 doesn't do more sqm with

do you think it has too good a connection for the game between ""

his ping is on waveform of 10ms

what are the advantages of having a fiber except a speed because I have the impression my feeling is that the vdsl2 is the best currently to play the games I make you share a recent gameplay, my character is fluid, my brother and his fiber has the character three times slower

I think you can still get a bit more speed from the rt3200, by switching from cake to fq-codel. But for a full gigabit SQM, you would need an x86 box.

Regarding VDSL, please realize that it is terminated in an ISP box 100-200 meters from your home. In that box, ISPs typically install their own access concentrator, which has VDSL lines on one end and fiber on the other. So the latency advantage may well be imaginary.

2 Likes

ok do you think it's because I reduce his bandwidth so much that this happens?

there is no real difference between his fiber without router and fiber with router



edit these are the 3 boxs of the provider they use i have the livebox 4 and my brother with his fiber the livebox 5 i see that the livebox 5 has a minimal processor compared to the others

first 1 livebox 6
seconde livebox5
three livebox 4

Based on your first waveform screenshot, I would say that the problem is not bufferbloat. It looks more like packet loss with some retransmissions, because they all are concentrated around 140 ms.

Here are my results, over 5 GHz WiFi, without SQM, on Globe Philippines (which is GPON fiber):

As you can see, they don't give me an A+, but still say that this connection can be used for low-latency gaming.

ok i see

the 4 5 dots grouped on the right means that a group of packages arriving is late? that's right

Yes. However, as they use TCP, these late packets might well be retransmissions due to bad-quality optical cable connections, because that's how TCP hides packet loss. Try reseating the fiber where it enters the modem.

1 Like

ok thanks for help i will try

The waveform test tries the 'impossible' (veridical delay measurements from within the browser*) and does admirably, I would not take each and every sample and deeply interpret it.

About your brother, what link technology PON or AON does he have, and what speedgrade (say GPON or XGSPON)?

*) Especially Safari is prone to produce/show delayed samples purely within the browser, firefox and chrome seem to be better in that regard, not sure however whether they are completely free of that issue.

hello the test was made from chrome google,

in France we use most of the gpon technology

ah my opinion I should think that the livebox 5 is not very powerful compared to the other liveboxes considering the processor

Better than Safari, but still a browser test.

As far as I know soime ISPs use GPON other already switched to XGS-PON, do you know which your brother uses?

Also ant idea about his ISPs segment size? Often ISPs will at most put either 32, 64 or even 128 users into a shared PON segment.

No idea on this, as it is hard to figure this out for someone as bad in french as me. I apologize for this, I should have payed more attention in school.

1 Like