AU: Cheap OpenWRT APs: what and where to look?

I am currently looking at buying some APs for a place I volunteer at. It's a volunteer budget (every dollar counts) and we are installing one AP at a time as they are needed (we also have to run ethernet). We're used to a dozen people hotspotting on phones, so anything will be an improvement.

Traditionally I have chosen which wireless access points to buy by going through what my local vendors are selling and cross referencing with the OpenWRT table of hardware & wiki. I'm in Sydney Australia, so I usually choose MSY, WES Wagner or IJK because they have physical stores to pickup from and shipping is otherwise a large chunk of the AP cost (unless I order in bulk, which is risky, as I learned when a vendor came up with another version of an AP in the same case that had an entirely different chipset in it :frowning:).

Using my traditional methods I found:

  • ASUS RT-AX53U (90AUD). It's big and fancy, making it a bit difficult to fit and mount near heritage items (can't drill holes in walls). Bought one and it's working.
  • TPLink TL-WR802N (35AUD). Would be very convenient to fit and install because it's small and has internal antennas (I love it), but it's only 8/64 and 2.4GHz radio only. I am tempted to buy and upgrade some (I have PCB rework experience and my hours are free).

Years ago I used some GL.iNet Mangos for some rollouts at work, but it looks like a lot of their products from the last few years cost a lot more (>100AUD each) and do not always support mainline OpenWRT.

I also found one interesting OM5P-AC on eBay second hand, but the seller is not responding to my messages. I've gotten lucky on eBay before but not always.

Question 1: Is ~90AUD the price floor I should expect now for an AP with good (16/64 or 16/128) OpenWRT support?

Question 2: Is it worth considering 2.4GHz-only APs (we have almost no wifi neighbours)? Or is ditching 5GHz silly thinking because we lose other things too? Eg it looks like many 2.4GHz-only APs do not meet minimum OpenWRT ram/flash requirements anyway.

Question 3: Any direct-from-china vendors worth considering? It looks like Banana Pi makes the cute BPI-WIFI6 for around 70AUD taxed and shipped, but it costs extra for antennas and it looks like it has no mainline OpenWRT support.

Question 4: Are single-antenna SBCs any good, or are they automatically far inferior to use as wireless APs than a router-like device with multiple antennas? Orange pi sells a few cheap ones with great RAM specs that are supported by OpenWRT.

Question 5: Any other hardware suggestions? :smiley:

https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/175415624270 seller got 5 pcs.

seems openwrt is picky with the boot loader version (assuming device ever came with more than one).

Ty frollic. For those specs at that price I am over the moon. Thankyou for the warning about bootloader, I might buy only one or two and then see how it goes so it's not too big of a loss if they don't work. I have some RS232 (high voltage) USB dongles and I am familiar with TFTP dances. It's only wifi-4 (5GHz n not 5GHz ac) but I do not think anyone will notice much, especially given how slow our WAN link is.

It also looks like the AP121 is cheaper and about the same vintage. 2x2 instead of 3x3. But the OpenWRT wiki page is a bit scarier, mentioning many bad vendor firmware versions and "Firmware images are not freely available for download and must be requested from the manufacturer". It's probably the same for the AP330 too but I guess I'll find out.

there's also the AirTight Networks C-75 / Mojo Networks C-75 / WatchGuard AP320 - https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/194034792880.

there's no wiki page and the git commit link is errors out (it happens now and then, keep trying it) - https://git.openwrt.org/openwrt/openwrt/commit/?id=0d96d36841e817f368e86d4af725570d757cb0ca.

Git commit mirror: https://github.com/openwrt/openwrt/commit/0d96d36841e817f368e86d4af725570d757cb0ca

looked there too, but I guess I didn't use the correct search term :frowning:

Yeah if you use Github's search for a commit hash then it tells you 'No results in the code', you then have to manually click "commits" on the left sidebar for it to search for those.

You have to think like a underpaid corporate UX designer that has been told to reduce database load :thinking:

another one: https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/128014959504

anyway, there're plenty of options out there, as you can see.

How are you finding these? They all seem to have "Wireless Access Point" in the title so are you doing a search for that and filtering by used + minimum price?

search for access point in networking, sort by price + shipping.

cross reference with https://firmware-selector.openwrt.org/?version=SNAPSHOT
if you get a hit, start looking for the git commit or a device wiki page.

Plus one for the AP121. Since you're familiar with the TFTP dance, they're easy to install.
Additionally the presence of the serial makes it my favorite "test AP" since I can always inspect and fix the config via serial if things would break (and not revert properly).
However, they're getting a bit outdated (wifi 4 only) unfortunately. For my "production" setup I've now switched to the EAP615, cheap, performant but PoE only.

PS: I'm working on OpenSOHO which might be useful for you to deploy your config to all the APs. (shameless plug, sorry)

Beggars can't be choosers. There are regularly very decent devices on your local second hand market places, but availability and pricing is unpredictable. It's quite rare to find good models with a longer term availability on the used markets, these are typically (ex-) ISP branded devices after 2++ years in the market, that are being replaced with a newer successor (Spectrum/ US has been one source like this in the past, there may be others around you).

If you do want a "go-to device" to standardize on, something available for the next 2-4 years to come, you will have to adapt your expectations and budget.

Regardless of all this, you should define your search parameters:

  • >>16/128 (no, I would not accept only 16 MB flash or less than 256 MB RAM (in practice 512 MB RAM) for a new purchase)
  • at least wifi 6 (802.11ax), wifi 5 (802.11ac) might do for a very cheap second hand device, if it ticks all your other boxes, but we do have decently priced wifi 6 devices these days, it does not make sense to go lower than that
  • concurrent dual-band, 2.4-GHz-only devices are obsolete for a decade (unless you're specifically looking for outdoor devices, different regulations… xor if you're looking for a warehouse-like environment, lots of 2.4-GHz-only 'IoT' devices, no throughput expectations, but even for those 2.4-GHz-wifi6 does bump the limit of maximum connected clients).
  • this effectively means ipq50xx/ ipq60xx/ ipq807x, filogic 820/ 830; mt7621a only if you specifically only need a cheap-cheap-cheap AP (not a router)
  • PoE or 'ruggedness' (suitable for semi-public installations, relatively 'tamper-proof') are aspects you need to consider (but that costs you dearly)
  • the Australian market is another can of worms (inflated prices and limited availability, compared to the rest of the world)

Usually I would suggest to check the market for potentially interesting devices in your budget first - and checking OpenWrt compatibility later, as that's usually easier than deciding on a model first and then finding out that you can't get it around your location (or prohibitively expensive).

Just because no one has explicitly told you so, scratch the tl-wr802n v4 from your list, mt7620, 8/64, 2.4-GHz-only, 100-MBit/s ethernet ports, this is obsolete for a decade. The same goes for the mango, verbatim. On top of this, those were primarily mobile routers, being small (and internal antennas) were the primary usage scenario for those, not range/ throughput.

For modern devices, you will expect at least 2 antennas, often 4 - 8 antennas (or more) for the high-end models (but those are out of your price range). Devices with a single antennas have 'always' (at least since wifi 4/ 802.11n) been cheap crap.

OK, but what are your requirements in terms of the wireless standards? Do you need AX or will AC suffice? (Given the budget constraints, BE is probably out of question.)

My personal favorite thing to do in this kind of situation is to go trawl eBay. And not just for access points, either; some consumer-grade routers make decent access points. I ended up with a Linksys WHW01 (also sold as VLP01) for access point, and I positively love it for the combination of low cost, small size, and tower form factor (the ruler in the photo below is, of course, marked in inches :zany_face:):

WHW01 is AC, but newer (and larger) models are AX. Netgear WAX202 and WAX206 are also AX. Speaking of Netgear, see if you can find a used WAX220 (it's an actual wall / ceiling-mountable AP), but chances are low (seems like everyone who has one loves it and doesn't want to let go of it).

Are single-antenna SBCs any good

Generally, no. First, external antennas are going away. The industry has pivoted to beam forming, and it requires multiple antennas with known physical spacing (hence, the proliferation of internal antennas). Second, if you want MIMO, you need multiple antennas. Third, a lot of single-antenna SBCs have Broadcom wireless hardware; some go even further into the badness and have it on the accursed SDIO bus...

$189 AU for 3-pack:
(https://www.jw.com.au/product/d-link-eagle-pro-ai-ax3200-mesh-system-3-pack)

$289 AU for 6-pack:
(https://www.jw.com.au/product/d-link-m32-eaglepro-ai-ax3200-mesh-system-6-pack)


$239 AU for 3-pack:
(https://www.jw.com.au/product/d-link-m30-ax3000-wifi-6-mesh-3-pack)

Not so picky, just the original contributor might not confirm it on other boot loader version. I just installed openwrt on one with "Aerohive Boot Loader v1.0.2.21". This version even lacks tftp capability, but images can be loaded from a usb drive. See the updated wiki.