24.10 EdgeRouter X, poor SQM performance

[moeller0]

@jotch

Can you see why this is needlessly frustrating to work with? If you doubt me at the very first step, it doesn't bode well for future steps.

As I tried to explain getting a measured goodput of 100 Mbps with a gross shaper setting of 100 Mbps is essentially impossible. So I am not doubting your data, but I want to understand why you see numbers that should be impossible.

@jotch

You asking for the same data that I already provided multiple times is what rubs me the wrong way.

A misunderstanding on my side then, I will hasppily wait for that data and make myself rare until then.

@jotch

I'm sad you see it this way, but I have better things to do than go back and forth with brada4

Look, I am not brada4 so not sure why you argue this with me. But I will just ignore that. In case you try again with OpenWrt24 and want some help with getting SQM to run properly or to at least understand what is different/wrong in 24 and why the performance crates, just post again to this thread and note. As I said, if you decide to leave this as is, no complaints from my side either.

[Summit48]

I would be concerned about the 4.50 % packet loss.

Can you set SQM Down/Up at 90/90 Mbps run the Cloudflare SpeedTest to see if you still get packet loss?

I am running OpenWrt 24.10.0 on a USG-3P with luci-app-sqm 25.066.49116~3182493, can you verify you are running the latest version of SQM?